Hi, I'm Carl Natale, the guy in charge of MaineToday.com's Outdoors section. I'm also a registered Maine sea kayak guide, an avid (winter) hiker, cross country skier, casual biker and a car camper. Here are my adventures.
I thought I was being healthy
Have you thrown away your Nalgene bottles yet? There is concern that your water will pick up Bisphenol A from your bottle and cause cancer.
The New York Times says Canadian Retailer Bans Some Plastic Bottles
A trade group says don't worry so much.
From what I can understand this can be a problem if the plastic is type "1," "4" or "7" and you:
Put very hot water into your bottles
Freeze water in your bottles
Keep bottles after the writing wears off. (That apparently is a rule of thumb)
Boiling and freezing can encourage particles of plastic and the chemicals that make up the plastic to to your liquid. If the bottle is old enough to lose its printing, the particles could naturally leach into your drink. Then the particles accumulate in your body.
Crap.
This winter I've been sticking Gatorade-filled Nalgenes (Yep, there's a "7" on the bottom.) into the microwave. Starting a winter hike with hot liquids can be a lifesaver. One of the bottles I used hasn't been readable for a year and half. And of course in the summer I like to freeze the bottles to make sure I can have a cold drink during the day.
About the only way I could make this worse is if I decorated the bottles with lead paint, filled them with hot tap water and kept them in asbestos insulators.
If falling off mountains doesn't kill me, will the Nalgene bottles? I could have skipped boiling water in my Nalgenes. But if I didn't start with hot bottles, they would have frozen in my pack. How's that for irony? And I remember when warm tea in a Nalgene seriously helped me stave off hypothermia during a rescue.
I come nowhere close to having the background and knowledge needed to advise anyone on this issue. But speaking personally, the risk was offset by the need. You can disagree and make your choice. Do your research.
Luckily, Nalgene will help me out. They're discontinuing BPA in their bottles. I can spend my stimulus check on new bottles.
Comments
Late to the party? I like to think that I arrived in time to help the host clean up the place.
And yes, I realize this has been an issue off my radar for awhile. But I hear the doorbell ringing. More people are fashionably late.
The problem with the upside down Nalgene bottle is that it allows you to access the very cold liquid. My concern is making sure I have something to warm me.
Also, the liquid still freezes. Which is one of the ways you can create a problem. Supposedly the freezing can break plastic particles away from the bottle.
April 29, 2008 11:35 AM
How about trying out a bottle that isn't manufactured by a company that also profits from vivisection. While looking out for your health, why not consider the health of some of our other planetary co-inhabitants. Check out Sigg bottles!
Posted by EarthaMay 3, 2008 10:26 AM




Recently Seen
Bayside World Market & Fair
Hailstorm in Jackman
Bridge Music Festival
'Ghost Town'
Stomp
Explore Maine
Maine Outdoor Journal
Carl - you are late to this party!
But you know, Nalgene makes other water bottles that do not have BPA and polycarbonates... I like the website
www.ReusableBags.com as they have lots of news and articles as well as cool products.
Also here's a tip that an outdoorsman taught me a long time ago: If you use a water bottle or nalgene-like bottle in the winter, stick it in the water bottle holder or pouch upside down. Ice forms on the top, so this way the mouth of the bottle doesn't freeze.
See you on the trails!
Posted by MelissaApril 28, 2008 07:45 PM